The Nanuet eatery -- what many call a "time warp" of a place -- won our DVlicious contest with 73 percent of the vote.
The eatery is known for its homey atmosphere and golden, thin-crust pizzas. Owner Paul Finnegan said Nanuet Hotel is special because they've used the same recipe since 1944. Go HERE for earlier Daily Voice story.
Nanuet Hotel Restaurant is at 132 Main St., (845) 623-9600.
Click here to follow Daily Voice New City and receive free news updates.