Pie Man Cottage In Valley Cottage Vies For Top Spot In DVlicious Contest

VALLEY COTTAGE, N.Y. -- We asked. You answered. In our hunt for the best pizza in Rockland, Pie Man Cottage was selected by you -- our readers -- among the top three.

A pie from Pie Man Pizza in Valley Cottage: no slices here.
Photo Credit: *Morganne Feingold*

Daily Voice

01/12/2016 6:00 a.m.

We still need your vote to crown the winner -- all finalists are being profiled this week -- but in the meantime, here's a "slice" of what makes this Valley Cottage pizzeria so DVlicious.

Pie Man Cottage, 107 Route 303, Valley Cottage, (845) 268-8797

In Business: Since 1947; purchased by new owners and renovated in 2011

Most Popular Slice Sold: Pies only. Plain.

Key to Success: "The fact that we've been around so long, that we're legendary, and everyone in the county knows us," said Bartender Morganne Feingold.

Voting is open until 5 p.m. Monday, Jan. 25.

CLICK HERE to cast your ballot. You can vote multiple times, though only once per day.

Click here to follow Daily Voice North Rockland and receive free news updates.