Marcos Tawil, was killed when the officer, Jonathan Mosquera, 24, of Suffern, tried to pass a 2008 Honda driven by Tzvi Hakakian, 19, of Monsey on the left as he was making a left turn into the Yeshivat Tiferet Tora.
The two cars sideswiped each other, sending the officer's car crashing into the teens before it hit an embankment and hit two trees, according to reports.
The other student injured, David Maldanado, is listed in critical condition at Westchester Medical Center. Both drivers received minor injuries, according to News 12.
Police investigating the crash have ruled out the use of drugs or alcohol as the cause. No charges have been filed, according to News 12.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Monsey and receive free news updates.