Christian Donahoe scored the game-winner for the eighth-seeded Indians. Dan Foley had two goals for Mahopac, which improved to 10-8. Fox Lane ended its season with a 12-5 record.
Mahopac will face Arlington in the semifinals on Tuesday, May 19.
The Section 1 finals are scheduled for Thursday, May 21 at White Plains High School.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Mahopac and receive free news updates.