Troopers responded to reports of grand larceny from the Delancy Street Foundation in Brewster in May 2012 and identified Michael Holt, 45, as a suspect, police said.
Holt was arrested in July 2014 in Connecticut on unrelated charges and was turned over to New York State Police, authorities said.
Holt is scheduled to appear in Southeast Town Court on Oct. 16, police said.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Mahopac and receive free news updates.