Craving a savory slice of pizza from Sullivan County? Look no further than these eateries, which were rated on Google as some of the best places for pizza in the area.
- Benji & Jake's (5 Horseshoe Lake Road in Kauneonga Lake)
With an impressive 4.5/5-star rating on Google, Benji & Jake's features much more than pizza on its expansive menu. From high-end meat cuts to vegetarian options like tomato fettuccine and fried vegetarian dumplings, there’s no doubt that those with even the pickiest palates will find something to enjoy.
Of course, Benji & Jake's is clearly known for its specialty pies, which are handcrafted using quality ingredients like black olive tapenade, house-roasted red peppers, shiitake mushrooms, goat cheese, house-made beer-battered fried jalapeño rings and more.
For more information about Benji & Jake's, visit the website.
- Paesanos Pizzeria (10 S. Main Street #1813 in Liberty)
Paesanos, which earned a 4.6/5-star rating, is known not only for its one-of-a-kind pies but for its affordable prices. From popular and savory appetizers like garlic knots to classics like wings, subs and more, you’ll have no problem finding the perfect sides to pair with your pizza.
For more information about Paesanos Pizzeria, visit the Facebook page.
- Danny's Steakout & Pizza (1869 Route 52 in Liberty)
With a near-perfect 4/7-5 star rating, Danny’s Steakout & Pizza, opened in 2016, packs a serious punch when it comes to both quality and variety. In addition to pizza, Danny’s also offers salads, homemade soups, wraps, Philly cheesesteaks and much more.
For more information about Danny’s Steakout & Pizza, visit the Facebook page.
- Gotta Luv It 4.5/5 (187 Kingston Avenue in Wurtsboro)
Gotta Luv It earned an impressive 4.5/5-star rating and offers a variety of handcrafted specialty pies and slices. Some of the pizzeria’s most popular slices include chicken bacon ranch, cordon bleu, bacon cheeseburger and more.
The eatery is also known for using classic Italian ingredients, such as pasta, as toppings for specialty pies.
For more information about Gotta Luv It, visit the unofficial Facebook page.
- Peppino’s Restaurant & Bar (31 Lower Main Street in Callicoon)
Considered to be the oldest pizzeria in town, Peppino’s, rated at 4.5/5, makes both the dough and sauce for its pies in-house each day. The pies, which are available in Neapolitan, Sicilian and specialty varieties, are made using fresh and local ingredients.
Peppino’s also serves other Italian classics like calzones, stromboli, various types of parmigiana, pasta, burgers and more.
For more information about Peppino’s Restaurant & Bar, visit the website.
Click here to sign up for Daily Voice's free daily emails and news alerts.