A bottle of white, a bottle of red? Perhaps a bottle of rose instead?
It's unclear what beverage he ordered, but one thing is not.
Long Island's own Billy Joel traversed the Long Island Sound to frequent a popular waterfront restaurant in Westchester.
The music legend left his Centre Island home in Oyster Bay to take a trip across the Sound to the Pier Restaurant and Tiki Bar in Rye, where he dined before heading back home to Long Island on Tuesday, July 16.
In photos posted on Facebook by the restaurant, Joel’s boat, “Alexa” can be seen docked near the popular restaurant, though no photos of the Piano Man himself were posted online.
"Guess who was in a 'tiki state of mind' - at the TIKI BAR," the post read. "If you guessed Billy Joel you were right!"
Click here to sign up for Daily Voice's free daily emails and news alerts.