The Tigers came into the match unbeaten at 7-0, adding to the drama.
But in the end, it was the Mounties - who scored early in the first, and led the rest of the way - who walked off with a 3-0 victory.
Michael Ruthberg scored Suffern's first goal, David Rozitis picked up his first varsity goal just over a minute into the third, and Evan Cama wrapped up the scoring five minutes later.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Armonk and receive free news updates.