The outlet looked at crime rates in municipalities with with 2,500 to 15,000 residents.
New Jersey is top in the country for population density and has the second-highest number of safe small towns, the outlet said.
"Small towns may bring to mind white picket fences, baseball, and Grandma’s apple pie. They evoke nostalgia for a simpler time when the streets were safe and people rarely (if ever) locked their doors," SafeWise said.
"While some of those sepia-tinted ideas have faded away (and several small towns are close neighbors to sprawling metro areas), the notion of safety in small towns is alive and well."
Not one violent crime was reported among the cities on this year's list.
These New Jersey towns were named:
- 99. Franklin Township
- 89. Closter
- 82. New Providence
- 78. Fair Haven
- 76. South Harrison
- 75. Norwood
- 67. Chatham
- 60. Hillsdale
- 59. Tewksbury
- 54. Matawan
- 53. Pennington
- 47. Chesterfield
- 44. Northvale
- 37. Old Tappan
- 31. Plumsted
- 25. Haworth
- 15. Mendham
- 6. New Hanover
Click here to follow Daily Voice Hackensack and receive free news updates.