The reason is simple - people love the food.
"We've been here a long time, we're near the ball field, and in town, so there's always a lot of people around," Manager Jesse Schewtschenko told Daily Voice. "They can walk here, and there's not usually a wait."
Aside from pizza, Nick's, owned by town councilman Nick D'Allessandro, makes great salads, grilled chicken, and lots of pasta dishes - and they're known for their large portions.
"People keep coming back," Schewtschenko said. "I think they're happy to come in because we always try to meet their special needs, and because they love the food."
Nick's Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta is located at 410 Rt. 376 in Hopewell Junction.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Poughkeepsie and receive free news updates.