The cafe, which is owned and operated by siblings Stephanie and Christina Evans and is known for its homey vibe, won with 42 percent of the vote. It was a close race, with Carmel Bagelicious just behind it, with 38 percent.
Our Town Bagels is at 961 Route 6, (845) 803-8745.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Mahopac and receive free news updates.