Kimberly Lovenberg, 41, was charged with theft by deception, Mount Olive Police said in a release on Monday, Oct. 31.
Detectives were first contacted by a victim claiming to be defrauded over Instagram on Thursday, Sept. 8.
The victim stated that Lovenberg had claimed to be a member of the Illuminati and could help them join.
Lovenberg was allegedly able to persuade the victim into sending her $5,444 through Venmo.
Lovenberg was previously hit with drug distribution charges in July 2021 after a suspected drug deal in Mount Olive, DailyVoice.com reported.
She turned herself into police headquarters on Friday, Oct. 28, and was released on a summons pending a court appearance.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Parsippany-Troy Hills and receive free news updates.