Ulster County may have plenty of pizza options, but it’s safe to say that some pizzerias simply stand above the rest in terms of freshness, style, quality and authenticity.
Fortunately, Google has all of the answers when it comes to restaurant ratings. If you’re puzzled on where to find your next piping hot slice, check out some of these highest rated pizzerias throughout Ulster County:
- Tony’s Pizzeria (582 Broadway in Kingston)
For more information about Tony’s Pizzeria, visit the Facebook page.
- Pie For The People (55 Washington Avenue in Kingston)
Pie For The People, which earned a respectable 4.7/5-star Google rating, is known for providing one-of-a-kind handmade pies using gourmet ingredients and toppings. In addition to offering various crust styles, the restaurant’s expansive menu features all things Italian: from calzones and strombolis to pasta, fresh salad and hot subs, you’ll have no problem finding the perfect meal.
For more information about Pie For The People, visit the website.
- Pomodoro Pizza Cafe (6 Haviland Road in Highland)
If you’re looking for a modern, eclectic twist on some Italian classics, look no further than Pomodoro Pizza Cafe, which earned a 4.6/5-star Google rating. Pomodoro’s menu is chock full of traditional fried foods like wings, fries and calamari, but you’ll also find plenty of fresh salads with house-made dressing and hearty calzones and baked specialties.
Of course, Pomodoro is best known for its piping hot pies, which can be topped with any combination of the restaurant’s signature ingredients like smoked bacon, herbed ricotta, roasted garlic, eggplant and more.
For more information about Pomodoro Pizza Cafe, visit the website.
- Enzo’s Ristorante & Pizza (207 Boices Lane in Kingston)
With an impressive Google rating of 4.6/5 stars, Enzo’s has the whole package when it comes to menu options, pricing and overall quality.
Enzo’s is known for its specialty pies, which range from savory selections like chicken and broccoli scampi to unique creations like the Greek, which includes feta, tomatoes, calamari olives, fresh garlic and oregano. But if you’re looking for a bit more variety, try some of the other traditional Italian cuisine, like seafood and pasta entrees, hot subs and sandwiches, burgers and more.
For more information about Enzo’s Ristorante & Pizza, visit the website.
- Di Bella’s Pizza Shop & Ristorante (405 Lucas Avenue Ext. in Kingston)
With a 4.6/5-star Google rating, Di Bella’s Pizza Shop & Ristorante has earned a spot on our list. Di Bella’s offers separate menus for its pizza shop and restaurant, and each features the best of the eatery’s homemade Italian creations.
Di Bella’s self-described “Showcase Pizza” includes some of the most popular specialty selections, including chicken bacon ranch, meat supreme, chicken part and classic white. Basic and premium topping options are also plentiful, giving guests the ability to personalize their pies to their heart’s content.
For more information about Di Bella’s Pizza Shop & Ristorante, visit the website.
No matter how you slice it, these establishments have proven themselves to be among the best of the best pizzerias in all of Ulster County. Eat up!
Click here to sign up for Daily Voice's free daily emails and news alerts.