Map Interactive local COVID-19 tracker
Contact Us
Suffolk Daily Voice serves Babylon, Brookhaven, Huntington, Islip, North Fork, Riverhead, Smithtown & The Hamptons
Return to your home site

Menu

Suffolk Daily Voice serves Babylon, Brookhaven, Huntington, Islip, North Fork, Riverhead, Smithtown & The Hamptons

Nearby Towns

  • Nassau
    serves Glen Cove, Hempstead, Long Beach, North Hempstead & Oyster Bay
Breaking News: Disbarred Attorney From LI Accused Of Stealing $372K In Escrow Funds
Lifestyle

Long Island Eatery Gets High Marks For Its Tasty Sauce, Classic Italian Staples

A cheese pie from The Gallery Four Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant
A cheese pie from The Gallery Four Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant Photo Credit: Gallery Four on Facebook

The winner of the Bethpage Best of Long Island Award for best Italian restaurant, Gallery Four has also won the hearts of diners for their house-made sauce, primo chicken parm, and reasonable price point.

"Lived in Lynbrook for 3 years and always drove by this spot but never went in, such a shame because this was the best sauce I have ever had here on Long Island," wrote Yelp! reviewer David D. of Gallery Four. "The decor is from the '90s but so are the prices and the food is great. 

"Our new favorite Italian spot, pizza is good because their sauce is sweet and not bitter like most places. Chicken park and shrimp parm for $14 you eat for two days. Love it!"

Founded in 1979, The Gallery Four Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant has been serving up pizzas and Italian classics to Long Islanders for years. 

The most expensive item on their menu, a Sicilian pie, is just over $20, with other pizzas costing $17.50 and a plain cheese pizza coming in at $13.95. Only a handful of menu items cost over $17. 

Among items on the extensive menu at Gallery Four are: 

  • A number of "antipasti" items, like fried zucchini, stuffed mushrooms, fried ravioli, cold antipasto, and baked clams
  • A sizeable pasta selection, including baked manicotti, stuffed shells, and homemade lasagna
  • Hot soups for under $5, including chicken noodle, minestrone alla Milanese and stracciatella alla romano
  • Stuffed eggplant, eggplant, chicken, veal, veal cutlet, and chicken cutlet parmigiana
  • Chicken Gallery, made with chicken breast in white sauce topped with ham, broccoli and mozzarella
  • Chicken marsala
  • Veal scallopine with peppers, veal scallopine marsala, and veal scallopine marsala with mushrooms
  • Chicken cacciatore 
  • Chicken Francese
  • Zuppa di clams ala posillipo
  • Mussels fra diavolo
  • Stuffed filet of sole

The restaurant also has a number of hero sandwiches and a selection of traditional pizza pies. 

"Nothing fancy but a good simple meal at a fair price with the nicest people," wrote Ed M. on Yelp! "Came here because we wanted just that, an unpretentious place that has good food. Glad we came, look forward to going back."

to sign up for Daily Voice's free daily emails and news alerts.

Welcome to

Suffolk Daily Voice!

Serves Babylon, Brookhaven, Huntington, Islip, North Fork, Riverhead, Smithtown & The Hamptons

Hi! You've read our articles so we know you like our reporting. To keep reading please join our mailing list.

Get important news about your town as it happens.