Officers responding to the 11:35 p.m. call on Linden Way found one of the girls drunk and unconscious, Detective Lt. John Bakelaar said this morning.
She and another girl were taken to The Valley Hospital in Ridgewood, he said.
Resident Marine Michaels, 20, was charged with maintaining a nuisance, while 21-year-old Robert Thompson of Oakland was charged with buying the booze for the minors.
Meanwhile, Cailen Alex and Karoline Intriago, both 19 of Wyckoff, were charged with underage consumption of alcohol.
All were released pending court hearings.
The two 17-year-olds, one from Franklin Lakes and the other from Oakland, will be issued juvenile complaints charging underage consumption of alcohol, Bakelaar said.
An investigation was continuing and additional charges may be filed, the lieutenant said.
The juvenile complaints are being forwarded to family court in Hackensack, he said.
Sgt. Karl Klein, Detective Sgt. Jeffrey Jost and Officer Gerard Gansel investigated.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Hackensack and receive free news updates.