Contact Us
Cresskill-Closter Daily Voice serves Closter, Cresskill & Demarest
Return to your home site


Cresskill-Closter Daily Voice serves Closter, Cresskill & Demarest

Nearby Sites

  • Northern Valley
    serves Harrington Park, Haworth, Northvale, Norwood, Old Tappan & Rockleigh
  • Englewood
    serves Alpine, Englewood, Englewood Cliffs & Tenafly
  • Bergenfield
    serves Bergenfield, Dumont & New Milford
Breaking News: Prosecutor: CT Pair Nabbed In NJ Turnpike Stop With Ghost Gun, Hollow-Nose Bullets
DV Pilot Police & Fire

NYC Men Nabbed By Closter Police In ID Thefts Free Again

Rory Bartley, Isaiah Penny
Rory Bartley, Isaiah Penny Photo Credit: MUGSHOTS: Courtesy CLOSTER PD

Two accused identity thieves from New York City were in the wind again after being arrested by Closter police.

Rory Bartley, of Brooklyn, and Isaiah Penny, of Queens were arrested on identity theft charges in December and subsequently released pending further court action, Closter Police Chief John McTigue said.

Detectives drew up additional charges after they said they tied them to what amounted to more than 50 bogus IDs.

The pair, both 22, were “involved in a conspiracy to defraud multiple victims’ identities, bank accounts and other personal financial accounts,” McTigue said.

Police re-arrested Bartley on Monday only to have a judge in Hackensack order him released from the Bergen County Jail less than 24 hours later under New Jersey’s 2017 bail reform law.

Penny, meanwhile, remained at large.

Both are charged with conspiracy, ID theft, trafficking in the personal identifying information of another and possession of false government documents.

to sign up for Daily Voice's free daily emails and news alerts.