New Milford Police Make Arrest In Tire Slashing Spree

NEW MILFORD, N.J. -- New Milford police ended a two-month search Thursday with the arrest of a man who they said slashed nearly 80 tires on more than three dozen vehicles during a pair of pre-dawn vandalism sprees, Daily Voice has learned.

Matthew DeStafano, 23, of New Milford

Matthew DeStafano, 23, of New Milford

Photo Credit: MUGSHOT: Courtesy NEW MILFORD PD

A caller brought Sgt.Nicholas DiGenio and Officers Kevin Morris and Christopher Bores to McKinley Avenue, where they spotted Matthew DeStafano, 23, of New Milford.

He was carrying a driver's side mirror and a pair of scissors, Police Chief Frank Ramaci told Daily Voice.

A canvass of the area revealed 15 vehicles with 41 slashed tires, which Ramaci said caused an estimated $10,500 in damages.

This comes after an Aug. 7 spree, in which 38 tires were slashed on 21 vehicles, he said.

Police charged Destafano with 29 counts of criminal mischief and released him without bail pending a court hearing.

Authorities had issued a sketch of their primary suspect based on interviews with witnesses a few days after the August attacks.

They described the vandal as white or light-skinned Hispanic, about 5-foot-8, with a chubby build, buzzed haircut and dark hair and eyes. He was wearing a hooded grey sweatshirt with possible writing on it and dark gym shorts, they said.

The summer attacks occurred between 1 a.m. and 5:30 a.m. on Charles Street and McKinley and Madison Avenues, Detective Kevin Van Saders said.

“All of the tires appeared to have been punctured with a flathead screwdriver type tool,” he said. “One of the vehicles was also significantly scratched up on its hood and driver’s side door.”

to follow Daily Voice Bergenfield and receive free news updates.