It wasn't long before our comment section was overflowing with other suggestions.
Turns out, many of you felt there were several other sandwich shops equally worthy of the prestigious title.
We combed through your suggestions and even polled you on Instagram and, well, you've got good taste.
These are the delis that came up the most:
Giovanni's Italian Deli, Secaucus
Tommy's Taste of Italy, Woodland Park
Click here to follow Daily Voice Bergenfield and receive free news updates.