SHARE

No Hung Jury This Time: Man Convicted Second Time Around For Killing Friend In Maryland

A man previously tried last year before being granted a temporary stay of execution by a hung jury was convicted of voluntary manslaughter for the death of his 33-year-old friend in 2021, authorities announced on Monday.

Jonathan Mohelski

Jonathan Mohelski

Photo Credit: Montgomery County State's Attorney's Office
Brandon Sutherland

Brandon Sutherland

Photo Credit: Montgomery County State's Attorney's Office
The knife.

The knife.

Photo Credit: Montgomery County State's Attorney's Office

Rockville resident Jonathan Mohelski, 39, will face a decade in prison in connection to the death of Brandon Sutherland in November 2021 following multiple trials, according to the Montgomery County State's Attorney's Office.

Mohelski was convicted following a 10-day trial after the jury wound up unable to reach a consensus in December 2023. 

Prosecutors say that Sutherland was staying at Mohelski's home in the 13000 block of Turkey Branch Parkway in Rockville when the latter made a 911 call stating that his guest "fell on something sharp in the bathroom" and "he might be dead on the floor." 

During the 911 call, Mohelski also stated that "I'm never going to forgive myself." 

Sutherland was found by first responders with a stab wound to his chest, and despite life-saving efforts by police, he was pronounced dead at the scene. 

A knife used in the stabbing was later found cleaned off, and re-sheathed in Mohelski's bedroom closet.

"It appears that a struggle took place in Mohelski's bedroom, as the folding closet door was caved in, and the mattress was hanging off the bed," court documents state. "A knife with suspected blood was found on the floor just outside the closet area." 

The blade was later tested for DNA, and Sutherland's blood was found to be present on the knife.

"We thank our prosecutors who remained dedicated to seeking a conviction following this senseless loss of life," Montgomery County State's Attorney John McCarthy stated. "We continue to express our deepest condolences to the family of Brandon Sutherland. The State will seek the maximum penalty at the sentencing hearing." 

Mohelski faces up to 10 years in prison. No sentencing date has been scheduled.

Want breaking news in the DMV as it happens, or want to contribute? Join the DMV All Incidents Facebook group.

to follow Daily Voice Bladensburg-Cheverly and receive free news updates.

SCROLL TO NEXT ARTICLE