After Daily Voice reported that an application to relocate White Manna's spot from 350 River St. to 112-120 Hackensack Ave. had been approved, readers made one thing clear: the tiny, decades-old diner is as much a destination as the burgers.
"The cramped old school location is 90 percent of the experience," one reader wrote on our Instagram post. "The burgers... well, this looks like a downward slide towards White Castle."
One customer who has been going for decades said a trip to the slider spot is almost like watching a well-rehearsed performance. Regulars know there's an unspoken rhythm to the tiny eatery, where everything happens in its own time, and newcomers quickly (or not so quickly) learn to follow along.
Another reader said moving the locale would end a family tradition, saying they wanted to take their own children to the same White Manna their father took them to.
"The nostalgia is what makes those burgers sell," someone else added.
The White Manna application, submitted by Esther Realty, calls for relocating the historic diner to 112-120 Hackensack Ave. and building a roughly 1,950-square-foot, one-story restaurant with an expanded kitchen, takeout service area, ADA-accessible dining room and restroom, an additional restroom and office space. Plans also include 17 parking spaces with EV charging, bicycle parking, landscaping, stormwater improvements, a new bus shelter area and the relocation of the iconic White Manna sign.
Not everyone was against the move, though.
One reader said the nostalgia is real, but so were the problems inside the current building.
"I've been going there since I was a kid and the nostalgia I feel toward the place is second to none, but the last time I was there, I sat on the far left of the counter and the odor of mildew coming from the rear area made it impossible to enjoy those great burgers. I, for one, would welcome a new location."
Another reader said the new setup could help business.
"They will make wayyy more money," they wrote. "I pass on goin there cuz u gotta pack in and fight to order"
One commenter pushed back on claims that the restaurant would lose its identity, saying the old location itself would be moved.
"Stop the misinformation. As you can see, they are moving the old location via truck to the new location, and adding and[sic] addition for more seating. Good luck, white manna, see you at your new spot."
It was not immediately clear if that was actually the case, though.
White Manna has operated for decades at its River Street location and is known for its slider-style burgers, drawing customers from across North Jersey and beyond. It has been named New Jersey's best burger spot and one of the best in America by multiple publications.
A traffic study submitted with the application said the relocation is not expected to significantly affect nearby traffic, noting many White Manna customers already travel the surrounding roads.
Click here to follow Daily Voice and receive free news updates.