SHARE

John Thomas Mathis Convicted In Bensalem Road Rage

A gun-wielding motorcyclist who threatened to shoot and rob another driver during a 2.5-mile road rage rampage before being shot by a Pennsylvania police officer has been convicted, authorities announced on Monday, Nov. 16.

John Thomas Mathis

John Thomas Mathis

Photo Credit: Bucks County DA
John Thomas Mathis

John Thomas Mathis

Photo Credit: Bristol Township PD
A Bensalem police vehicle

A Bensalem police vehicle

Photo Credit: Facebook/Bensalem Police Department

John Thomas Mathis, 45, of Levittown, was found guilty on Friday, Nov. 13, of multiple felony firearm and assault offenses stemming from the Saturday, Aug. 2, 2025, confrontation in Bensalem Township, according to Bucks County District Attorney Joe Khan.

The verdict followed a trial that began Tuesday, Nov. 10, before Senior Judge Thomas C. Branca.

Mathis was convicted of prohibited possession of a firearm, carrying a firearm without a license, terroristic threats, possession of a weapon, possessing an instrument of crime, simple assault, recklessly endangering another person, evading arrest or detention on foot, and related summary traffic offenses, prosecutors said.

Motorcyclist Threatened To Shoot, Rob Driver

The terrifying encounter began around 5:43 p.m. on Aug. 2, 2025, when Mathis, riding a black Kawasaki Ninja motorcycle, began driving aggressively along a 2.5-mile stretch of northbound Bristol Pike in Bensalem Township, investigators said.

The victim testified that Mathis pointed a handgun directly at their face and threatened to shoot and rob them before they managed to drive away and call 911.

Mathis continued following the vehicle northbound on Bristol Pike, according to prosecutors.

A Bensalem Township police officer responding to the emergency call caught up with the vehicles near Bristol Pike and Appleton Avenue and positioned his patrol cruiser between the victim's car and Mathis' motorcycle.

As the officer exited his cruiser, Mathis fled on foot while holding a handgun in his right hand, investigators said.

The officer repeatedly ordered Mathis to stop and show his hands, but he refused to comply, according to prosecutors.

During the confrontation, Mathis held the handgun in a reverse-style grip aimed toward the officer, according to findings previously released by the Bucks County District Attorney's Office.

The officer fired three shots, striking Mathis twice near his left shoulder blade and once near his right armpit.

Mathis fell to the ground, and responding officers immediately began providing lifesaving medical care.

He was transported to Jefferson Torresdale Hospital, where he underwent surgery and survived.

Investigators recovered a black 9mm handgun at the scene that was not registered to Mathis. His prior felony convictions legally prohibited him from possessing firearms, prosecutors said.

The occupants of the victim's vehicle and the officer were not injured.

Officer's Shooting Ruled Justified

In September 2025, then-Bucks County District Attorney Jennifer Schorn announced that the officer was justified in shooting Mathis.

The determination followed an investigation by Bucks County Detectives that included reviewing body-worn camera footage, police radio transmissions, witness statements, and surveillance video from nearby businesses.

Schorn concluded that the officer reasonably believed his life and the lives of nearby motorists and civilians were in immediate danger.

The officer's actions also complied with Bensalem Township Police Department use-of-force requirements and countywide law enforcement guidelines, prosecutors determined.

Already Wanted For Another Road Rage Incident

At the time of the shooting, Mathis was already wanted in connection with a separate July 27, 2025, road rage incident in Bristol Township.

In that case, Mathis was accused of intentionally causing two collisions before getting out of his vehicle with a baseball bat and smashing another driver's windshield and driver's side door, according to authorities.

Bristol Township Police issued an arrest warrant on July 29 charging him with simple assault, possessing instruments of crime, criminal mischief, recklessly endangering another person, disorderly conduct, and harassment.

He also had multiple outstanding criminal matters in Bucks County, including an aggravated assault while DUI case in Bristol Township, receiving stolen property cases in Bristol Borough and Lower Southampton, and a fleeing incident in Middletown Township.

Prosecutors previously said Mathis had been placed on pretrial supervision with GPS monitoring in May 2025 despite objections from the District Attorney's Office.

He repeatedly violated his release conditions and even cut off his GPS monitor, prompting a judge to revoke his bail and issue bench warrants just days before the August shooting, according to the DA's Office.

Those Bucks County cases have since been resolved.

Mathis has already been sentenced to nine and a half to 19 years in state prison, followed by three years of probation, after being found guilty of aggravated assault by vehicle while DUI, prosecutors said.

Philadelphia Armed Robbery Charges Still Pending

About an hour before the Bensalem shooting, Mathis allegedly entered a Metro by T-Mobile cellphone store in Philadelphia, displayed a black semiautomatic handgun, and stole cash before fleeing northbound into Bucks County, according to prosecutors.

The Philadelphia armed robbery charges remain pending.

Prosecutors Praise Verdict

Deputy District Attorneys Megan Stricker and Catherine Pirolli prosecuted the Bensalem road rage case, presenting testimony from victims, Bucks County Detectives, and Bensalem Township police officers.

Both prosecutors returned to the District Attorney's Office earlier in 2026.

Following the verdict, Khan praised their work and the officer who confronted Mathis.

"Bringing back seasoned, battle-tested prosecutors like Megan and Cate has bolstered our ability to hold violent repeat offenders accountable," Khan said.

"This verdict is a testament to their courtroom expertise and the bravery of the Bensalem police officer who stepped directly into harm's way to stop an armed suspect. My office will always stand shoulder-to-shoulder with the dedicated men and women in uniform who keep Bucks County safe."

Bucks County Detectives William Mooney and Kelcy Pitts investigated the case along with Deputy District Attorney Megan Hunsicker.

Sentencing on the latest convictions has been deferred until January 2027, prosecutors said.

to follow Daily Voice and receive free news updates.

SCROLL TO NEXT ARTICLE