East Fishkill police responded to the store on Route 82 in Hopewell Junction after Jeremy Mishk, 36, stole more than $400 worth of merchandise from the store, police said.
A witness provided police with a description of the car and within several minutes the car was stopped by a Dutchess County Sheriff's Deputy on Route 55 in LaGrange.
Mishk, who was a passenger in the car, was turned over to East Fishkill Police and the property was recovered, police added.
He is being held at the Dutchess County Jail on $5,000 cash bail or $10,000 bond.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Southwest Dutchess and receive free news updates.