39°
Middletown has a growing number of pizza options, but those that offer true quality, authenticity and value are few and far between.
That being said, Google has all the answers when it comes to restaurant ratings. Here are five of the highest-rated pizzerias throughout Middletown:
- Pizza E Birra (287 NY-211 in Middletown)
With a 4.5/5-star rating on Google and a near-perfect 4.8/5 stars on Facebook, Pizza E Birra in Middletown serves a huge array of Italian specialties. On the menu, you’ll find some of everything, including classic soups, salads, pasta, burgers, calzones, seafood and much more.
Of course, pizza remains the star of the show. The fresh dough is made in-house and topped with a signature blend of flavorful toppings. Popular options include the Giada (smoked BBQ pulled pork, jalapenos, chopped tomatoes, cheddar jack cheese and olives) and the Funghi E Cipolle (sauteed mushrooms, caramelized onions over goat cheese with honey truffle oil and fresh thyme).
Don’t forget to pair your pie with one of Pizza E Birra’s many craft beers, or stop by during Happy Hour (Monday through Thursday from 3:30 p.m. to 6:30 p.m.) for additional daily food and drink specials.
For more information, visit the website and Facebook page.
- Colandrea Pizza King (360 NY-211 in Middletown)
Another Middletown pizza staple, Colandrea Pizza King is going on its fourth decade in business since opening its doors in 1980. Needless to say, Colandrea’s many years in business have earned the establishment a stellar 4.6/5-star rating on Google.
In addition to serving a variety of appetizers, burgers, salads, calzones and more, Colandrea’s is known for its one-of-a-kind specialty pies and slices. Try the restaurant’s thin crust pizza, the stuffed pizza and the Philly cheesesteak pizza, which includes grilled onions, sauce and American and Mozzarella cheese.
For more information, visit the website and Facebook page.
- Cosimos Brick Oven Ristorante & Bar (620 NY-211 in Middletown)
Cosimos, which has opened locations in Middletown as well as Poughkeepsie, Woodbury and Newburgh, has undoubtedly established itself as an area staple. With a 4.5/5-star rating, Cosimos serves all things Italian, from arancini and Caprese to flatbreads, pasta, burgers and of course, wood-fired pizza.
Cosimos is known not only for its variety of pies but for its perfect use of signature toppings like herbed ricotta, roasted garlic, roasted zucchini, sun-dried tomatoes and more. In fact, the restaurant has nearly 20 different specialty pie combinations - or, you can create your very own.
For more information, visit the website and Facebook page.
- Joey's Pizza (4.5/5) (88 Dunning Rd #11 in Middletown)
Of all the pizzerias listed here, Joey’s offers the biggest variety in both style and topping. With a 4.5/5-star rating, Joey’s serves traditional and Sicilian style pies, including many of its own signature styles such as Pizza Di Nonna, Grandma Pizza, Mom’s Home Pizza, stuffed pizza, deep-dish pizza and of course, specialty gourmet pizza.
Dairy-free and vegan pizzas are also available - as are hot and cold subs, chicken wings, salads and more.
For more information, visit the website and Facebook page.
- Frank's Pizza & Italian Restaurant (470 NY-211 in Middletown)
Last but certainly least on our list of top-rated Orange County pizzerias is Frank’s, which earned 4.4/5 stars. Frank’s serves everything from pizza and pasta to soups, salads, paninis, subs and more. Some of the most popular pie varieties include chicken parmigiana, buffalo chicken, eggplant and ricotta and chicken fajita. Square Sicilian-style pizzas and individual specialty slices are also available.
For more information, visit the website and Facebook page.
Click here to follow Daily Voice South Orange and receive free news updates.
